Susan Landau: Thou Shalt Not Bulldoze Thy Neighbor’s House

(A presentation given at St. Martin-in-the-Fields Church, Philadelphia, St. Nicholas Day, December 9, 2012)

THOU SHALT NOT BULLDOZE THY NEIGHBOR’S HOUSE

By Susan Landau

Thank you for inviting me to be here with you on St. Nicholas Day.  The Church of St. Martin in-the Fields is an inspiring example of how a community of faith can promote awareness and respond to injustice in Israel-Palestine.   Your ongoing commitment to the American Friends of the Episcopal Diocese of Jerusalem makes life livable for so many Palestinians in need.  The extensive scope of your work in supporting hospitals, health clinics, schools, parishes, and service organizations in Palestine, Israel, Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan demonstrates humanitarian aid at its very best.

As Christians and Jews, we are in this together. I have come to understand that it is important for Christians to hear Jews talk openly about the injustice in Israel-Palestine. Many of you have Jewish friends with whom it is difficult for you to have these conversations.  They may disagree with the perspective I will offer.   I know that.  And you know that there is no consensus within the American Jewish community on Israel.  Marc Ellis, renowned Jewish liberation theologian, refers to people like me as Jews of conscience.   We, Jews of conscience, count on Christian allies like you to speak truth and move this work forward.

Toward that end, know this: It is NOT anti-Semitic to criticize the policies and actions of the Israeli government and to demand that Israel comply with international law.

I was raised in and embraced the ethical tradition of Judaism.  The concept of mitzvoth, that commands we love all our neighbors as ourselves, is the bedrock of Judaism.  The Torah teaches that human beings are created B’tzelem Elohim – in the image of God.  That’s how I see the world.  You do, too, right?  Our interfaith work is grounded in our common humanity.   All human beings are equally worthy of respect, dignity and love.

For Jews, the overarching framework for social justice is found in two Hebrew words: g’milut hasadim and tikkun olam.  G’milut hasadim, is defined ‘acts of caring’, such as direct help to people in need.  Tikkun olam, literally translated means ‘repair of the world’, which entails advocating for structural (political) change.  We make a distinction between these two ways to respond to injustice.

Some examples may help to illustrate how this works:  Providing temporary shelter such as through the Interfaith Hospitality Network, offering food as do programs like Meals on Wheels and soup kitchens are examples of g’milut hasadim.  On the other hand, Heeding God’s Call, anti-fracking advocacy are examples of tikkun olam.  The New Sanctuary movement has elements of both.  Escorting immigrants to detention hearings (accompaniment) would be g’milut hasadim; advocacy to pass the Dream Act would be an example of tikkun olam.

With this in mind, I’d like to use our time together to consider how faith informs one’s relationship to the peoples and place of Israel-Palestine. Three questions emerge:

  1. What do you see?
  2. How do you frame what you see?
  3. How does this understanding inform the choices you make about whether and how you will respond to the situation?

Question Number One: What do you see?  Whether or not you have been on a delegation and seen the situation first-hand, and/ or participated in the Steadfast Hope course…

In November the world watched in horror as images flooded the newspapers and television –targeted assassination, rockets fired into southern Israel, Israel’s bombs descending on Gaza, destruction, death, terrorized children, under-equipped overly-crowded hospital rooms, grief, pain, and suffering for Israelis and Palestinians.  Humanitarian need in Gaza, already off the charts due to the blockade, rose exponentially.   Without question, humanitarian aid was and is essential to maintain even a modicum of level of subsistence for the people in Gaza.

Now zoom out, the context is political.  Two nationalisms competing for land and resources, an Israeli military occupation of Palestine well funded by US tax dollars, resistance by Palestinians.

Violence on all sides.  And the land is holy.  And the people are, too.  All the land and all the people.

Question Number Two: How do you frame what you see?  A frame is a way of seeing the world, of making sense out of information, a worldview. I offered a values frame of G’milut hasadim and tikkun olam.  Consider others:

  • How does the Gospel Mandate for peacemaking frame your understanding of what you see?
  • Or consider the frame of competing nationalisms?  What are the implications of the fact that the indigenous population lost rights to their land and resources, and that the process continues to this day?
  • Or the framework of international law and human rights in which the Geneva Conventions and numerous UN resolutions frame the debate?
  • Or the frame of civil rights.  In October a delegation of civil rights organizers who worked with MLK, including historian Vincent Harding and Dorothy Cotton, along with Rabbi Brian Walt, Rabbi Emeritus of Mishkan Shalom and others, traveled to Palestine to meet with grassroots organizers.  Together they launched the idea of framing of the Palestinian struggle as the civil rights movement of our time.

Question Number Three: How does your understanding inform the choices you make about if and how you will respond to the situation? Given your frame, how do you respond to the suffering in Palestine?

Humanitarian aid is straightforward and uncomplicated.  It’s g’milut hasadim.  Providing food, medical aid, and insuring education absolutely alters lives.  Yet humanitarian aid falls short of altering the relationships of power that control people, land, resources, and the economy.  These are political issues; they too must be addressed.

It is our responsibility to understand and to acknowledge what is at the core of the problem – political realities of occupation, collective punishment and siege.  As people of faith, we readily identify basic rights and respond to basic needs- the right to education, the need for blankets, books, and medicine.  But borders and bombs must also find their way into our conversations.

Here’s why – as Americans, we provide tax aid to Israel that builds and maintains the infrastructure of occupation that creates the humanitarian crisis.  We are complicit.   U.S. military aid given to Israel is used to oppress Palestinians.  U.S. aid builds illegal settlements, the wall, provides cluster bombs and white phosphorous for assassinations and warfare, and electronic surveillance at checkpoints.  Private corporations such as Caterpillar and multi-national corporations such as Hewlett Packard profit from Palestinian suffering by providing everything from bulldozers for home demolitions, to high tech systems used to monitor and control Palestinians at checkpoints, and more.

Unless we address both human need and the political context, we maintain the status quo. Consider the Free Gaza Movement’s repeated attempts to Break the Siege of Gaza by sending flotillas – ships such as the Free Gaza, the Liberty, Mavi Marmara.  Their mission was not only to deliver humanitarian aid to an imprisoned population starving under brutal Israeli policies of occupation and blockade, but also to create an international spectacle.

For example, in South Africa the strategy “If people see what is going on, they will act” was used by the international community in supporting the ANC to bring apartheid to an end. The popular slogan “The whole world is watching,” galvanized ordinary citizens to act in support of the rights of black South Africans.  Similarly, the global movement for a just peace in Israel-Palestine uses media to draw public attention to Israel’s violations of international law.  It took a long time, but apartheid ended.  And churches were at the fore of that movement.

How does faith shape our response to the people and land of Israel-Palestine?  My answer is “Thou shalt not bulldoze thy neighbor’s house.”  Let me explain… In 2003 twenty-three year old American peace activist and International Solidarity Movement member Rachel Corrie died in Gaza.  She was murdered by an Israeli soldier commandeering a Caterpillar bulldozer as she was protesting a policy of the Israeli government – the demolition of Palestinian homes.  Rachel wasn’t in Gaza providing food or blankets.  House demolitions are a violation of Palestinian human rights.  Rachel’s protest was a political act.

Tikkun olam – fix what is broken in the world.  I stand with the Israeli Committee against House Demolitions, ICAHD, in advocating for the fundamental rights of Palestinians by vehemently protesting the policy of home demolitions. And I promote the boycott of and divestment from Caterpillar, the company that sells the bulldozers that knowingly will be weaponized in Israel for precisely this purpose.

Guided by Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel’s teaching, “Few are guilty, all are responsible,” my faith inspires me to stand for justice.  My response to a world that is broken is Tikkun olam.  Being an activist for justice for all people in Israel-Palestine is a sacred expression of what it means for me to be a Jew.

Today many Christians are mobilizing their communities around Kairos Palestine, 2009, a document to the world from Palestinian Christians about what is happening in Palestine.  This again follows in the tradition of the South African Kairos document launched in 1985 as a significant tool in the struggle against oppression.  Kairos South Africa, “A Challenge to the Church,” begins, “This is Kairos, the moment of grace and opportunity, the favorable time in which God issues a challenge for decisive action.”

Likewise, Kairos Palestine is a word of faith, hope, and love from the heart of Palestinian suffering.  It is an appeal to Christians to support initiatives proposed by Palestinians, such as the 2005 Call by Palestinian civil society for boycott, divestment and sanctions against Israel until it complies with international law.  Bishop Dawani is an original signatory to this document.  A more recent initiative, Kairos USA, 2012, is intended to mobilize churches in the United States to respond faithfully and boldly to the situation in Israel-Palestine.  Among its authors is Rev. Cotton Fite of the Episcopal Peace Fellowship/Palestine Justice Network.

These are some brave initiatives within the Episcopal Church:  In addition to the American Friends of the Episcopal Diocese of Jerusalem, The Palestine Justice Network of the Episcopal Peace Fellowship provides valuable resources.  Among its projects has been promoting and making available the Steadfast Hope curriculum.

However, there is still much work to be done.  A few weeks ago, a number of concerned U.S. religious leaders wrote a letter to Congress asking for scrutiny into how US aid is used, specifically whether Israel is in violation of the Foreign Assistance Act and the US Arms Export Control Act.  The gist of the letter was that U.S. military assistance given without accountability or conditions maintains Israel’s military occupation of Palestine.  Both laws prohibit assistance to any country which engages in a consistent pattern of human rights violations.  The Arms Export Control Act further limits use of U.S. weapons to internal security and legitimate self-defense, both of which have been questioned in Operation Cast Lead and Pillar of Cloud, the recent invasions into Gaza.  Sadly, the Episcopal Bishop did not sign this letter.

How is this to be understood?  What is to be done?  As American citizens it is essential that we hold our government to the standard of its own laws.  As people of faith, we are called to respond to injustice.  Communities of faith must hold leadership accountable.  The church has a critical role in Israel-Palestine, as it did in the civil rights movement and in ending Apartheid South Africa.  Different situations, yes – but in each situation, injustice necessitated a political response.

What do you see? What is your frame for understanding what you see? And, what will be your relationship to this injustice?

Susan Landau is an activist, organizer, and founding member of Christian-Jewish Allies of Greater Philadelphia.   Susan participates in interfaith teaching teams offering The Steadfast Hope educational curriculum on Israel-Palestine in local church communities. She helped to found American Jews for a Just Peace and its Philadelphia chapter, Philadelphia Jews for a Just Peace (PJJP).  Through her work with the Philly BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) coalition, she helped to launch the local boycott against Sabra Hummus and Tribe Hummus.  In addition to her longtime career as a psychotherapist, Susan has worked as a Jewish educator, committed to creating honest curriculum on 1948 and the Nakba which makes the distinction between Judaism and Zionism.  She is an involved member of Congregation Mishkan Shalom in Philadelphia, PA.

Brian Grieves: Balance and Dialogue as a Substitute for Advocacy and Justice?

Balance and Dialogue as a Substitute for Advocacy and Justice?

Advocacy by Christian Leaders: Recently, Palestinians lost 170+ lives in Gaza and Israelis lost 5+ in a wave of violence, and just averted a war with a tense ceasefire, while the United Nations has granted the Palestinians observer status as a state and Israel has announced plans to build settlements that would be the last nail in the coffin of a two state solution.  Meanwhile, back at the ranch that is sometimes called the Episcopal Church (TEC), there has been considerable consternation that TEC declined to participate in an October 5 letter to Congress calling for hearings on foreign aid to Israel. All the major denominational leadership signed the letter: Lutheran, Methodist, Presbyterian, the United Church of Christ and others. The decision to sit this out is a critical blow to TEC’s advocacy in the Palestinian/ Israeli conflict built over three decades and reflects not just on TEC leadership, but on the whole Church.

The mainline denominations that wrote and signed the letter includes the Christian membership of an eight year Jewish/Christian dialogue of which the Episcopal Church is a founding member (2004).  The decision not to participate in the letter put the Episcopal Church in the lonely position of being the only Christian member of that dialogue to abstain.

And it is not as if TEC lacked policy. The General Convention held in July in Indianapolis voted (A-015) to reaffirm the 1991Resolution A149, which “require(s) the State of Israel to account to the Government of the United States for all aid to Israel…in compliance with the Foreign Assistance Act.”  This is precisely what the letter to Congress is about!  Yet the Episcopal Church chose not to participate despite the invitation to do so. The Church’s own policy base has been thwarted.

Dialogue AND Advocacy: The letter to Congress is issued in the context of eight hard years of this dialogue with the mainline Jewish organizations in the United States, who have as a primary objective the defense of the State of Israel. That’s different than a commitment to a just peace.  This is not a criticism, just an observation of an important dynamic. Having participated in five of the eight years of that dialogue, and having organized for the Christian membership an historic joint Jewish/Christian trip to the Holy Land in 2005, I am aware of the deep gulf that separates the Christian witness for justice of these denominations versus the Jewish organizations perspective of solely defending the “Jewish state” of Israel.  While we were respectful of each other we rarely were able to find consensus.   Nonetheless, the experience was invaluable and revealing.  And I enjoyed a number of friendships in those Jewish organizations despite our differences, and they even defended Desmond Tutu from charges of Anti-Semitism at my request.  But it felt to me as if the Jewish organizations were more interested in managing us than in serious dialogue that would lead to a joint justice oriented position to end the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.

Now, the letter to Congress has emerged. The Jewish organizations have predictably howled, saying they were blindsided and not consulted ahead of time, as if the signers violated some protocol.  For years, Jewish organizations have asked that TEC share resolutions being prepared for General Convention or Executive Council.  They actually suggested they should have some kind of censorship role.  Of course, when we asked how they’d respond to us reviewing their many web postings on the conflict prior to publication they would demure.  Instead, one issued a fund raising appeal naming mainline denominations as villains against Israel. But we didn’t walk away from the table.

I discerned from these organizations that there are certain lines over which we as Christians could not be allowed to cross, for example, any sort of boycott, divestment or sanctions, or making comparisons to Apartheid, or as in this case, questioning Israel’s use of foreign aid.  The Church must always be “balanced” as if this conflict is between two equal parties. Justice is to be sidelined in favor of balanced statements, neutrality, silence and polite dialogue. If this had been the methodology of the Churches towards South Africa, Apartheid would still be alive and well. Israel has been oppressing the Palestinian people during 45 years of Occupation, to say nothing of the second class status of Israel’s Palestinian citizens.  In this context, dialogue has its place and can be an important component of peacemaking, but it cannot be a substitute for advocacy and the pursuit of justice.  There has to be a both/and approach.  The latest issue of Cornerstone from Sabeel is devoted to interfaith dialogue and contains important insights.

An emergent Jewish critique: Marc Ellis, an American Jewish scholar, recently offered these insights on Jewish/Christian dialogue and the letter to Congress:

It seems late in the Israel/Palestine political game – and it is late indeed – but the mainstream Churches are breaking… the interfaith ecumenical dialogue, the post-Holocaust place where Jews and Christians have mended their relationship. Israel was huge in this dialogue. Christians supported Israel as repentance for anti-Semitism and the Holocaust….

Just as aspects of Jewish support for Israel are dropping off, liberal Christian support is ebbing…. I’m thinking specifically of the October 5 letter that a group of prominent Church leaders sent to Congress. In the letter, Church leaders admonish Congress for allowing Israel to skirt and in some cases violate American law. They are direct and to the point, especially highlighting American foreign aid to Israel…. In a stunning departure, interfaith relations are secondary to the immediate needs of the Palestinian people who are under assault by Israel.

Reading the letter out loud I marvel on the distance traveled. Despite the pressure and with support as well, is there any way back to the pieties of yesteryear for these Church leaders?

Strange, looking on the internet for commentary on the Church leaders’ letter, one site had the letter opposite a quotation from the Holocaust survivor, Elie Wiesel: ‘Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.’

It seems that the Church leaders have finally learned the central lesson of Christian complicity in the Holocaust. It was taught to them by Jews in the personal witness of Elie Wiesel.

The lesson: The ultimate sin is silence in the face of injustice.  

Conclusion: The letter to Congress is a watershed moment.  While the denominations have separately held similar policy positions over the last few decades of which Ellis may not be aware,  joint letters such as this have been rare, making this one all the more poignant.  And for some troubled Episcopalians committed to a just peace, the decision not to sign the letter has cast a shadow over the conscience of the Episcopal Church.

The Reverend Canon Brian J Grieves, Former Peace and Justice Officer,  The Episcopal Church, 1988-2009

December 2012

 

American Muslims for Palestine Support Church Leaders

October 25

Dear Church Leaders:

The American Muslims for Palestine, a national, grassroots organization dedicated to educating Americans about Palestine, would like to offer our wholehearted gratitude for your letter asking Congress to hold Israel accountable for its many human rights abuses of Palestinians and repeated violations of international law. As the largest Palestinian-led organization in the United States, we also would like to offer our support.

As an organization on the forefront of social justice work for Palestine in the US, AMP hopes to grow grassroots support that eventually will pressure Congress to craft a more balanced Middle East foreign policy, which will guarantee equal rights for everyone living in the Holy Land. Your letter is an important step in helping Americans embrace this struggle as one of their own. US unconditional support for Israel is harming the perception of America throughout the world; it also threatens our national security.

We gratefully acknowledge that your letter reflects the positions of your respective churches and organizations regarding human rights violations by Israelis against Palestinians, the expansion of Israeli settlements in occupied territory, and the right of Israelis and Palestinians to live in peace and security. We agree wholeheartedly with your statement that unconditional US military aid contributes to “the deteriorating conditions in Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories which threaten to lead the region further away from the realization of a just peace.”

As is to be expected, you are now enduring verbal assaults from those who support the status quo in the Holy Land. Remain firm, and know that Palestinians in the United States, as well as abroad, are heartened by your actions and stand by you during this time.

Sincerely,

Dr. Hatem Bazian
Chairman, American Muslims for Palestine

 

Palestinian Christian Alliance for Peace Letter to Congress

Washington DC
October 31, 2012

We write today as Palestinian American Christians in support of the October 5th letter by fifteen U.S. Christian leaders who called for an investigation of possible Israeli violations of the U.S. Foreign Assistance Act and the U.S. Arms Export Control Act, and, more broadly, whether our aid to Israel is undermining prospects for peace. The letter also urges Congress to hold hearings and regular evaluations to examine Israel’s compliance with the two afore-mentioned Acts, and suggests the possibility of withholding military aid for non-compliance.

Many of us maintain strong connections to our families and churches in the West Bank, Jerusalem and Gaza. When we travel to visit our loved ones and the Holy Places, we observe first hand the extreme hardships they face under Israeli occupation. We see America-made weapons wielded by Israeli soldiers at checkpoints that enforce the fragmentation of Palestinian communities and separate Palestinians – Muslims and Christians alike, from their places of work and worship, their farms, schools, and hospitals. We see the ruins of Palestinian homes demolished by weaponized, American-made Caterpillar bulldozers to make way for Jewish-only roads and settlements built on confiscated Palestinian land, in contravention of international law and numerous U.N. resolutions. These bulldozers are exported to Israel under the Foreign Military Sales Program.

Many of us emigrated because life under occupation was increasingly unbearable. Most of us know at least one Palestinian family that has suffered a loved one being imprisoned with no due process, land being confiscated, or business shut down because of the severe barriers on movement and commerce. We could not bear to see our children confronted by an Israeli military that too often uses deadly force against peaceful protests. Christian communities in the Holy Land reach back to the very beginnings of Christianity, but many of our Christian brothers and sisters continue to flee from the intolerable conditions of occupation. The result is that the very existence of indigenous Palestinian Christians in the Holy Land is threatened. Our churches, many of which are among the holiest sites for Christians around the world, used to be vibrant with worship ceremonies and celebrations; now they are in danger of becoming lifeless museums for foreign pilgrims and tourists to visit.

As American Palestinians, it pains us that our adopted country, which prides itself on respect for human rights, is the main arms supplier to an occupation army that uses force to oppress our people, steal their resources, pauperize them, and generally threaten every aspect of their lives.

We quote from the Kairos Palestine: A Moment of Truth – A Word of Faith, Hope and Love from the Heart of Palestinian Suffering, signed by Patriarchs and Heads of Churches in Jerusalem:

“After prayer and reflection, we cry out from within the suffering in our country, under the Israeli occupation… Today, we bear the strength of love rather than that of revenge, a culture of life rather than a culture of death… Our word to the international community is to … insist on the [implementation of] international resolutions regarding the Palestinian problem.”

We believe that the letter of the fifteen Christian leaders asking Congress to investigate all U.S. military aid to Israel is an appropriate response to the Kairos Palestine call for true peace and justice. It is in this spirit that we wholeheartedly support the clergy’s letter.

Blessings and peace,

Tarek Abuata, Philip Farah, Paul Noursi, Grace Saïd, and Ghassan J. Tarazi
Steering Committee of Palestinian Christian Alliance for Peace

Our Lord’s call “to preach good news to the poor ….”

The following is an excerpt from a book to be published by Palestinian Christian Samia Khoury.

…what drew a lot of attention and controversy was the letter sent to the Congress on October 5, 2012 by 15 prominent American Christian leaders. “As Christian leaders in the United States,  it is our moral responsibility to question the continuation of unconditional U.S. financial assistance to the government of Israel, as continuing such aid will only serve to sustain the status quo and Israel’s military occupation of the Palestinian territories.” The letter  also  called on Congress to make military aid to Israel “contingent upon its government’s compliance with applicable U.S. laws and policies.”  Unfortunately the Presiding Bishop of the Episcopal Church did not endorse the letter, and the Episcopal public policy director, Alexander Baumgarten said that the request for congressional hearings was not in line with Episcopal policy.  I have never heard of a church policy that can possibly contradict with the demand for human rights.  After all did not our Lord come “to preach good news to the poor, proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to release the oppressed.” (Luke 4:16)

As a result of this letter, Leslie Scanlon reported in the 19th of October issue of the  Outlook National Reporter that tensions are running high between Jewish groups and an alliance of mainline denominations, and that in response, leaders of Jewish groups have canceled a meeting of an interfaith group that had been scheduled for Oct. 22-23. Leaders of Reformed and Conservative Jewish groups, the American Jewish Committee and other Jewish groups sent a letter Oct. 17 expressing their distress and saying they would not attend a planned meeting of the Christian-Jewish Roundtable, an interfaith discussion group formed in 2004.

“Considering the vehemence of such a response, one might assume that the Christian leaders’ letter was filled with outrageous and incendiary anti-Israel rhetoric.  But in fact their letter is a sensitively worded and faithful call supporting “both Israelis and Palestinians in their desire to live in peace and well-being” writes Rabbi Brant Rosen in the Jewish Journal on  October 24. He explains that there has long been an unwritten covenant between the Jewish establishment and Christian leaders when it comes to interfaith dialogue: “We can talk about any religious issues we like, but criticism of Israel’s human rights violations is off limits.”  He goes on to explain why the Jewish establishment reacted so violently to a relatively balanced and religiously based call? Because by speaking their conscience, these Christian leaders had the audacity to break the unwritten covenant: “If you want to have a dialogue with us, leave Israel alone.”

If that is the case then unfortunately those Jewish leaders who decided not to attend the roundtable meeting will not be missed.  And if interfaith dialogue is simply another tool or another body not much different from the US administration in shielding Israel from accountability, then it would be a futile exercise.  One would hope that interfaith dialogue is supposed to bring together the moral values of each faith so as to enhance understanding promote peace, and encourage people to work for a better world for all. Unlike politics, there should be no double standard in genuine interfaith dialogue and no vested interests, otherwise it will end up being  a cosmetic and hypocritical dialogue.

A similar reaction took place earlier when the Board of  Deputies of British Jews pulled out of meetings in July 2012 with Lambeth Palace, the official residence of the archbishop of Canterbury, because the Anglican’s highest legislative body voted overwhelmingly to strengthen ties with the Ecumenical Accompaniment Program in Palestine and Israel, an initiative of the World Council of Churches. “The (EAPPI) program brings internationals to the West Bank to experience life under occupation. Ecumenical Accompaniers (EAs) provide protective presence to vulnerable communities, monitor and report human rights abuses and support Palestinians and Israelis working together for peace.”  Once again,  exposing the truth is basically what worries the Jews who support Israel.

 

2012 Diocese of Maine Resolution re Palestine/Israel Peace

RESOLUTION FOR DIOCESE OF MAINE CONVENTION

 RESOLUTION PROPOSAL: Palestinian/Israeli Peace

SUBMITTED BY:  Episcopal Peace Fellowship – Maine Chapter

CONTACT:  Maurine Tobin

Resolved, that the 193rd Annual Convention of the Episcopal Diocese of Maine, acknowledging the Church’s regret at the lack of progress in negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians toward a just and peaceful resolution of the longstanding conflict in the Holy Land, urge each congregation in the Diocese to continue to pray and study the situation in the Holy Land through resources such as the annotated bibliography to be prepared and posted on The Episcopal Church website as well as existing resources such as Steadfast Hope and Kairos Palestine, the Episcopal Peace Fellowship of Maine providing facilitators if requested, and be it further

Resolved, that in response to urging from the General Convention, the Diocese of Maine commit in 2013 to offer support tothe Al Ahli Arab Hospital of Gaza, an institution of the Episcopal Diocese of the Jerusalem, by requesting that Episcopal Peace Fellowship of Maine provide educational programming for congregations on the work of the hospital and to solicit financial support for its work, and be it further

Resolved, that the Diocesan Convention request the Trustees of Diocesan Funds to adopt the recommendations of the Executive Council of The Episcopal Church (see Appendix 2) with regard to corporate engagement. Specifically we request that they:

 1)  provide information regarding our Diocesan portfolio, including profile share of companies that invest positively in Palestine or that negatively affect life in Palestine;

2)   file shareholder resolutions or other formal communication with companies in the Diocesan portfolio “which operate in the Occupied Territories” and “contribute to the infrastructure that supports and sustains the Occupation, such as settlements and their bypass roads, the security barrier where it is built on Palestinian land, and demolition of Palestinian homes” urging them to cease to do so;

3)  report to the 2013 Diocesan Convention regarding actions taken by the Trustees and the responses they receive from the companies so engaged.

Explanation:

Supporting information for these resolutions is found below in Appendix 1 (Resolutions B017 and B019 adopted by the 2012 General Convention of the Episcopal Church) and in Appendix 2, an Executive Council resolution passed in October 2005 that calls on The Episcopal Church to support both positive investment and corporate engagement with companies contributing to violence against either side or practices that sustain occupation.

NOTE: The first two sections of the resolution passed overwhelmingly; the third failed 141 – 93.

 

Jimmy Carter Backs Church Letter on Israel

Demand To Review Aid Has Roiled Jewish Relations

Former President Jimmy Carter commended a letter from Christian leaders to Congress calling for an investigation of Israel for human rights violations that could lead to a suspension of military aid.

“Like these church leaders, The Carter Center has long been concerned about Israel’s disregard for stated U.S. policy,” said a statement issued Wednesday from the human rights group named for and headed by Carter. “This is demonstrated by an unprecedented massive increase in encroachment on occupied Palestinian territory, with illegal settlement expansion during recent years.”

“This is precluding the possibility of a two-state solution and endangers a peaceful future for both Israelis and Palestinians,” Carter said in the statement.

Jewish groups in mid-October pulled out of an interfaith dialogue after 15 leaders from mainline churches sent the letter to Congress, with no advance notice to their Jewish interlocutors.

The Jewish Daily Forward, October 31, 2012

 

Samia Khoury to Anglican and Lutheran Bishops

Dear Bishops:

I thought this would interest you regarding the letter that was signed by the 15 Christian leaders to the Congress. They are indeed to be commended on this initiative. While the Lutheran Presiding Bishop has signed it, it is surprising to note that Episcopal Presiding Bishop did not. “Not in line with Episcopal policy does not hold water.” The Lutherans and the Episcopalians are the only two churches in the US that have communities in Palestine, so their voice needs to be heard. For the church abroad to be concerned about the dwindling numbers of Christians does not help when they do not raise their voice to put an end to the occupation and the violations of human rights. Please make an effort to support those voices who finally had the courage to speak up and not worry about interfaith dialogue that seems to be the Jewish trump card everytime the church attempts to raise its voice.

Respectfully,

Samia

Samia Nasir Khoury was for 17 years the President of Rawdat El-Zuhur, an elementary school in East Jerusalem.  She has served on the board of the Sabeel Ecumenical Liberation Theology Center and the board of trustees of Birzeit University.

 

Rabbi Brian Walt in Haaretz

Christian leaders cannot be cowed into silence over Israel’s abuses of human rights

Eric Yoffie’s criticism of the Protestant churches’ letter to Congress is misplaced: The price of ‘interfaith dialogue’ cannot be silenced by Christian leaders on Israel’s human rights violations, evidence of which I saw firsthand in a recent visit to the West Bank.

By Rabbi Brian Walt | Oct.31, 2012 | 5:54 PM |  7

In his recent Haaretz op-ed, “Heading toward an irreparable rift between U.S. Jews and Protestants,” my colleague, Rabbi Eric Yoffie, sharply criticized the recent letter to Congress by leaders of Protestant churches that called for U.S. military aid to Israel to be contingent on Israeli compliance with American law. Nowhere in his article, however, did Yoffie mention the central concern of the Christian leaders’ letter: the overwhelming evidence of systematic human rights violations by the Israeli military against Palestinians.

Over the past two weeks, I had the privilege of leading an interfaith delegation including several leaders of the civil rights movement, younger civil and human rights leaders, Christian clergy, academics, and several Jews, on a two-week trip to the West Bank.

We were all shocked by the widespread human rights violations that we saw with our own eyes and that we heard about from both Palestinians and Israelis. Several black members of our group, including those who participated actively in the civil rights movement, remarked that what they saw on the West Bank was “frighteningly familiar” to their own experience, a systemic pattern of discrimination that privileged one group (in this case, Jews) and denigrated another (Palestinians).

Together we walked down Shuhadah Street in Hebron, a street restricted to Jews and foreigners where Hebron’s Palestinians are mostly not allowed to walk, even those Palestinians who own houses or stores on the street. This street was once the center of a bustling Palestinian city. Now the area is a ghost town with all the Palestinian stores shut down by the Israeli military.

We visited several villages on the West Bank whose land has been expropriated by the Israeli government and where their nonviolent protests against this injustice are met with rubber bullets and tear gas (we saw with our own eyes many empty canisters of tear gas made in the U.S.). We witnessed a demonstration in Nabi Saleh, watching soldiers in armored cars launch tear gas and shoot rubber bullets against children who were throwing stones. In this village, soldiers routinely enter homes in the middle of the night to arrest children, who are handcuffed and blindfolded, and taken to interrogation without the right to the presence of a parent or of consultation with a lawyer. The shocking abuse of children that we heard about from several sources, including Israeli lawyers, was particularly disturbing.

Our delegation also saw the rubble of Palestinian houses demolished by the Israeli authorities and waited in long lines at check points as Jewish motorists were waved through or passed unimpeded through special settler checkpoints.

We met with a young Palestinian man who played the part of Martin Luther King Jr. in a play about Dr. King’s life written by one of the people on our trip. This young man (like over 140,000 other West Bank Palestinians) has lost his residency rights as he went to Europe to study acting. Despite the fact that his family has lived in Jerusalem for generations, he is now unable to live in the city in which he was born. Yet I, or any other Jew, could become a citizen of Israel overnight and live in Jerusalem while enjoying many privileges available only to Jews.

Every day we were on the West Bank, we saw this pattern of discrimination: a systemic privileging of one ethnic group over another. Every day we heard about egregious human rights violations: Administrative detainees held in prison for years without any right to due process (a Palestinian due to talk to our group about prisoners was arrested two days before the presentation and is still in prison), massive land confiscation, separate roads and grave restrictions on movement.

As the Christian leaders’ letter indicated, all the violations we witnessed are made possible by unconditional American aid, in violation of American law. Rabbi Yoffie predicted that this statement may cause “an irreparable rift between U.S. Jews and Protestants.” It may be more accurate to say it may cause a rift between the American Jewish establishment and the Christian leaders who have until now been cowed with the warning that the price for “interfaith dialogue” is silence on Israel’s human rights violations.

But after these past several weeks, as I read the courageous Christian leaders’ letter and stood side-by-side with my interfaith colleagues on this remarkable delegation, I sense a new form of interfaith cooperation – one based in our mutual sacred imperative to “seek peace and pursue it.”

Rabbi Brian Walt is the Palestinian/Israeli Nonviolence Project Fellow of the Dorothy Cotton Institute. He was the executive director of Rabbis for Human Rights-North America from 2003-2008.

An Open Letter to the Presiding Bishop, Katharine Jefferts Schori

An Open Letter to the Presiding Bishop, Katharine Jefferts Schori
From the Palestine Justice Network of the Episcopal Peace Fellowship

Dear Bishop Katharine:

We write as fellow Episcopalians who share your deep interest in “a just and peaceful resolution to the Arab-Israeli conflict” as stated in your letter to the two major political candidates for President of the United States on October 12.  Our membership includes many seasoned people who have traveled extensively to Israel and Palestine, some of whom have lived in the region for a number of years.  We are comprised of lay and ordained members, including bishops.  We hope our letter today will further the interests of not only dialogue, but advocacy on behalf of the just peace that we both deeply desire for Palestinians and Israeli Jews.

We particularly appreciate your pointing out a number of the complexities that make progress towards justice challenging, including a potential “nuclear Iran; continued Israeli settlement building, particularly in and around Jerusalem, at a pace and pattern that complicates the territorial contiguity of a future Palestinian state; unacceptable levels of violence on all sides; and the humanitarian disaster of the Gaza Strip.”   You also correctly point out that even though “only direct bilateral negotiation between Israelis and Palestinians themselves can bring about a just and lasting peace, history is clear that American political leadership has the power to play a catalytic role in supporting the work of peacemakers.”

This latter point, with which we share agreement, leads us to ask why you have not yet signed the letter from our ecumenical partners to Congress calling for an accounting of U.S. aid to Israel.  The General Convention just completed in Indianapolis voted (A-015) to reaffirm Resolution 1991-A149, which “require(s) the State of Israel to account to the Government of the United States for all aid to Israel…in compliance with the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961.”  It also calls for “hold(ing) in escrow aid to Israel by an amount equal to any expenditures by the Government of Israel to expand, develop or further establish Israeli settlements in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem, and only release the aid from escrow if proof is given that settlements are not being established.”  Given the explicit nature of our Church’s policy we are perplexed that you have not yet signed onto the letter to Congress.  We could not have a clearer policy base for you to join in this important initiative.  We hope to see your name added in the coming days.

We would also like to point out that your letter to the presidential candidates fails to describe accurately the current state of affairs in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories.  One might imply from your letter that there are two equal parties to the conflict.   In fact, your letter does not once mention the word “occupation.”  (Nor did the General Convention 2012 resolution B019).  We wonder if your failure to mention the occupation is deliberate or just an oversight.  No one who is uninformed would understand from your letter that the state of Israel has been oppressing the Palestinians living in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza since 1967.  We cite the B’Tselem report, “No Minor Matter” as evidence of Israel’s treatment of Palestinian children as just one of many forms of human rights abuses committed by Israeli entities.   B’Tselem is a respected Israeli organization.  Our own State Department has also noted significant human rights abuses by Israel in its annual human rights report.  We also commend the latest issue of Cornerstone, a publication of Sabeel, which writes about children being held under Israeli military detention.  500-700 children are prosecuted in Israeli military courts each year.  The description of detention of these young people is heartbreaking.  We commend the full issue to your attention.

We would add that unless American political leadership is willing to hold Israel accountable for acts – past and present – that undermine movement toward a just peace, restarting bilateral negotiations may create the illusion of progress but will simply condemn the Palestinians to continued loss of their land and resources.  “Supporting the work of peacemakers” must include addressing the immense imbalance in power that has characterized negotiations during both the Bush and the Obama administrations and drains these and possible future talks of any hope for successful resolution.  Negotiations must be matched by actions on the ground that support, not undermine, the talks themselves.  Again, we appreciate your noting this concern.

Because of so many documented human rights violations by the state of Israel, the letter to Congress could not be more appropriate.   The current impasse in negotiations makes inevitable a third intifada, the nature of which we can only speculate about.  The letter to Congress sends an important signal to all the parties that U.S. Christians stand for human rights across the board, without exception, and is an important advocacy effort that could help forestall another intifada.  Palestinians on the ground need to see that others understand their daily suffering and are speaking out.  Otherwise, the voices of extremism will drive events.

We appreciate your reminder to the candidates that “a two-state solution is the shared policy of the United States government, the government of Israel, and the Palestinian National Authority.”   But as you no doubt already know, many expert analysts, including American and Israeli Jews, are making the case that the policy of Israeli appropriation of Palestinian land and its unrelenting expansion of illegal settlements, has or soon will make a two-state solution impossible.  Many of our members believe the two-state solution has already been foreclosed.  Your letter correctly acknowledges that settlement building “complicates the territorial contiguity of a future Palestinian state.”  The irony is that Israel through its settlement policy is forcing a one state bi-national solution as the only alternative, which many Jews see as the end of Israel as a homeland for the Jewish people.   The only other option would be for Israel to force Palestinians into a non-viable, non- contiguous state that will be judged by the world as another apartheid system, which will lead to an inevitable movement for a bi-national state.  We believe our Church should review its policy of support for a two-state solution in light of Israel’s continuing expansionist policies that seriously draw into question its commitment to this goal.   Ultimately, as you have noted, Israeli Jews and Palestinians must resolve this issue.

There is much else left unsaid here that we hope we might pursue in future dialogue with you.  Again, we are grateful to see you engage this most pressing of all international conflicts, and we seek to find a common witness from our Church on behalf of justice for oppressed Palestinians and liberation from the role of  oppressor by Israel  so that our common vision of peace and security can be realized for all Israeli Jews and Palestinians.
Faithfully and with gratitude,

Steering Committee, Palestine Justice Network/Episcopal Peace Fellowship:
Ann Coburn, Cotton Fite, Brian Grieves, Donna Hicks, Edward LaMonte, Grace Saïd, Newland Smith, Cabell Tennis, Jessie Vedanti

Linda Gaither, Chair, National Executive Council, Episcopal Peace Fellowship
Allison Liles, Interim Executive Director, Episcopal Peace Fellowship

To the IDF Soldiers at Sabra and Shatila

To the IDF soldiers who were at Sabra and Shatila,

September 2012 will mark the 30th anniversary of the massacre at the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps in Beirut. In 1982, the first day of Rosh Hashanah coincided with the final hours of that horrific event.  This year, the first day of the Jewish New Year, September 16, corresponds with the opening hours of the killings.

I met you in 1982. I was working as a nurse at a hospital in Sabra.  I arrived after Israel’s invasion of Lebanon, soon after Israel refused to allow food, water, and vital medications into the besieged city.  I was there as a humanitarian.  Morally, I could not stand by and be silent while the destruction of a city and the killing and maiming of its people happened.

Following the assassination of the newly-elected president of Lebanon in mid-September all hell broke loose. I listened as Israeli planes broke the sound barrier over the camps,heard continuous heavy artillery fire, and stayed away from shattering windows.  For almost 48 hours, from September 16th to the 18th, I attempted to save the lives of those who were brought to the hospital. Many had severe wounds from being shot at close range. I cared for hundreds of terrified refugees seeking the safety of the hospital.  I tried to comprehend the throat-slitting gesture the women made. I watched from a top floor of the hospital as flares were shot in the air. The flares illuminated areas of the camp; the sound of automatic weapons fire followed each illumination.

The first day of year 5743 was marked by the arrival of the Phalangists -you who were there remember that extremist militia – at the front of the hospital. They ordered the international health workers toassemble.  They marched us down the main street of the camps: past dead bodies, past a bulldozer marked with a Hebrew letter which was shifting soil to cover over a large area where homes once stood.  Many of the militia were using walkie-talkies.  At one point, the soldiers lined us up against a bullet- ridden wall and pointed their rifles at us.  After several minutes, they put their rifles down and marched us out of the camp.

They led us up a street to an abandoned UN building.  In the courtyard we saw parts of IDF uniforms, discarded army rations and recent editions of the Israeli newspaper Yedioth Ahronoth.  After interrogating us, they took us across the street to the Israeli Defense Forces forward command post.  It was located in a five story building thatoverlooked the surrounded camps; we saw soldiers looking down on the camps with binoculars. It was there that you and I first met.

A number of you had on kippot (skullcaps) and tallitot (prayer shawls) and were reading from prayer books.  It was mid-morning; perhaps you were reciting the Amidah (the Prayer) which consists of many prayers including one for peace, goodness, blessings, kindness and compassion.  One of you offered a nurse a piece of carefully wrapped honey cake – maybe your mother had given it to you to take along on your army duty.  I have never forgotten this gesture.  Traditionally, we begin the New Year by eating something sweet – usually honey cake – to symbolize our hopes for a sweet year.  But as I think back, I am pained by the act of celebrating the Jewish New Year as thousands of innocents were buried in mass graves below.

One of you said “Today is my Christmas.” I knew what you meant.  For us, this day begins ten days of introspection and repentance when the Book of Life is opened and our fate for the next year is sealed.

In September, I will return to Beirut, as I have every year – to remember, commemorate, visit the mass grave, reunite with survivors, stand next to those who lost loved ones and bear witness.

I wonder what has happened to you over the past three decades.  I know that EmilGrunzweig, a Peace Now activist, was murdered in February of 1983, during a demonstration – one of the largest in Israel’s history – demanding that Prime Minister Begin adopt the recommendations of the Kahan Commission that investigated the massacre. Lt. Avi Grabovsky testified before the Commission. Ari Folman made a movie: Waltz with Bashir.

What about the rest of you?  Many of you have children, maybe grandchildren. Do you live in comfortable housing; do you feel a sense of safety and security in your homes and neighborhoods? Are you well fed? Did you obtain a proper education, earn a decent living, and have access to health care, travel? Do you enjoy life? What are you passing on to the next generation?

Let me tell you about what life is like for the Palestinians I know still living in Sabra and Shatila. More than 9,000 refugees live within one square kilometer.  Most of the dwellings are overcrowded, damp, and poorly ventilated; some have tin roofs. Open sewage systems run through the camps. The population is vulnerable to hostilities between various political factions. Refugees are denied the right to work in most jobs. Impoverished, they depend on an already overworked and underfunded UNRWA for basic health services and education. Inadequate nutrition, chronic illnesses and poor health are common. Children are deprived of a good education. Many refugees have never been out of their camp! Third and fourth generations are being born, growing up, and dying in these camps. It is bleak and appalling. The future holds little hope for any improvement in their lives.

I know that you are not to blame for the way the Palestinian refugees live today. I just ask that you take a few moments during one of our holiest days to remember. I am thinking of both you and of the Palestinian refugees during this time and I wish for a better future for all of us.

To the soldier with the honey cake, to the one who told me it was his Christmas, and to the others, L’Shana Tovah  5773 – To a good year.

Ellen Siegel

Jewish Voice for Peace Support for Sabeel

A Statement of Support for Sabeel

As rabbis and people of faith, we stand in solidarity with the work of Sabeel.

Palestinian Christian liberation theologians such as Canon Naim Ateek of Sabeel challenge Jews and Christians to rethink our relationship to the Holy Land and each other on the basis of a universal standard of human rights grounded in nonviolence. Canon Ateek sees us as equal theological partners in the land we both love – and Sabeel’s partnership model provides a hopeful model for dialogue and action. We encourage the Jewish community to engage the Palestinian Christian faith community with an open heart and mind in order to encounter another version of faithfulness.

We are aware that many Jews point to the more radical incarnations of some of Ateek’s theological images. We believe, however, that it is a mistake to dismiss Palestinian Christian theology wholesale. As Jews, we are much more troubled by the “End of Days” theologies of fundamentalist Zionist Christians such as Pastor John Hagee, who believe that Jews will either convert or go to hell when we’ve fulfilled our theological purpose. This is anti-semitism par excellence.

The Palestinian people live in the face of daily brutality by those who are destroying their homes, confiscating their land and water, manning the checkpoints that prevent freedom of movement to hospitals, work and study, shooting tear gas during demonstrations and dropping bombs in civilian areas. Needless to say, many Palestinians do not possess positive feelings toward the people who perpetrate these kinds of actions. Nonetheless, an amazing movement for nonviolent resistance has arisen in Palestine – and Sabeel is part of this movement.

We have much to learn about the faithfulness of thousands of Palestinians toward nonviolence. Jews who are upset with Sabeel need to ask the following question: what kind of nonviolent leverage does a disadvantaged people use when so much power is aligned against them? This is the heart of the question that Sabeel have been exploring for decades: how to struggle nonviolently against Occupation.

We believe this is an extraordinarily important question with which to begin an interfaith dialogue.  Granted, it will invariably be a difficult conversation, but it is one in which we simply must engage. At the end of the day, contemporary interfaith cooperation and reconciliation must be grounded in a shared understanding of human rights. Authentic prophetic faith challenges us in painful ways because, as Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel reminds us, it upsets the status quo.

After all, isn’t this one of the central lessons of the Holocaust: that every person, group and country is accountable to the same human rights standards?  When the Declaration of Human Rights was written in response to the Holocaust, Jews were grateful for a universal measure by which to judge human behavior.   We believe groups such as Sabeel to be our partners in affirming these sacred standards – that are rooted in our shared conviction that all human beings are created in the image of God. We are proud to stand together with them in our shared work of justice, dignity and liberation for all.

Signed,

Rabbi Brant Rosen, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Alissa Wise, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Lynn Gottlieb, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Rachel Barenblatt, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rain Zohav, Rabbinical Student, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Joseph Berman, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Laurie Zimmerman, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi David Mivasair, JVP Rabbinical Council

Cantor Michael Davis, JVP Rabbinical Council

Ari Lev Fornari, Rabbinical Student, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Zev-Hayyim Feyer, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Brian Walt, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Julie Greenberg, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Eyal Levinson, JVP Rabbinical Council

Michael Ramberg, Rabbinical Student, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Michael Feinberg, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Margaret Holub, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Rebecca Lillian, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Elizabeth Bolton, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Haim Beliak, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Rebecca Alpert, JVP Rabbinical Council

Rabbi Jeremy Milgrom, JVP Rabbinical Council

 

Palestine Justice Network | Copyright © 2026 All Rights Reserved

2045 West Grand Ave, Suite B #40058, Chicago, IL 60612-1577

in**@****jn.org

LOGIN