Ungrounding: The Architecture of Genocide, by Eyal Weizman
PJN member Harry Gunkel reviews the book, Ungrounding: The Architecture of Genocide, by Eyal Weizman.
In 1950 Israeli forces dug a shallow trench to mark the boundary between the Gaza Strip and the new state of Israel. That line in the ground, still recognized by Israel, was the first line drawn in the architecture of the genocide in Gaza that began with the Nakba and continues today. In his new book, Ungrounding: The Architecture of Genocide, Eyal Weizman gives us an entirely new way of thinking about the genocide: an architectural perspective that reveals its schematics, detailing the ways Israel has been using Gaza’s ecology and geology to bring about its annihilation. Weizman sees architecture as not just buildings and designs but also what has been unbuilt, the pre-existing life worlds that have been destroyed.
The concept of “ungrounding” goes beyond the destruction of surface structures; it entails desertification of Gaza, transforming it from a Palestinian homeland going back centuries to a barren, empty place rife for development. The ideal expressed by some of the Zionist planners of this architecture was to make it unrecognizable to those who had inhabited it, to remove the indigenous people’s rootedness in the land and make way for the colonizers. Ungrounding “aims to remove a society from its place and erase all traces to its previous existence…It is not a by-product of military confrontation but rather its aim. It destroys all conditions that sustain life…The monochrome desert of upturned soil is the material signature of Israel’s genocide.” Destroying the conditions that sustain life violates Article II(c) of the Genocide Convention, which prohibits indirect forms of killing such as destruction of the environment and infrastructure that undermines a people’s ability to survive. This is the element of genocide that ungrounding addresses.
Eyal Weizman is a self-described “Israeli-born Jewish person” who left Israel, “unwilling to build my life under a regime of Jewish supremacy”. He is an architect and founder of Forensic Architecture, a London-based non-profit investigative agency that mobilizes architectural knowledge and technologies to investigate state violence. The material in this book is a small part of Forensic Architecture’s contribution to the case for genocide made by South Africa at the International Court of Justice. Importantly, Weizman explains that Forensic Architecture’s work “is not taken from a position of neutrality. Our principle of ‘engaged objectivity’ makes us take sides, never with the state, and always with those exposed to state violence”. It is important to emphasize, however, that the taking of sides is not politically or militarily based – there is no reference here to “self-defense”, land promises, or “terrorism” per se; but derives from the meticulous analysis of the actions taken by the state of Israel and their results.
Ungrounding: The Architecture of Genocide has three parts. The first, “Soil”, details the ways that the ground and the place of Gaza were the basis for the architecture of genocide: three geologic zones going from the Mediterranean coast inland, first sand and dunes, then loess and clay, then agriculturally fertile soil, each zone rising in elevation to form three ridges stretching north to south. These zones are graphically displayed in multiple maps and aerial views that give us a startling and novel picture of Israel’s strategy for the dispossession and mass murder that unfolded over decades.
Part II is “Subsoil”, a fascinating description and analysis of the tunnels in Gaza, which Weizman describes as “the shadow of the political history on the surface”. He notes that they are the only part of Palestine left unoccupied. We all hear a great deal about the tunnels, most of it untrue. For many Israelis, the tunnels under Gaza fed the hasbara about Palestinians’ subhuman status, infesting the earth like vermin. But in truth, as the book explains, the tunnels are a complex system of multiple functions, designs, and purposes that continues to defy Israel’s attempts at destruction.
Part III is “Ungrounding”, the section that gives us the horrifying dimensions of the genocide and their coldly calculated murderous nature. The events of October 7 and 8 are recounted in detail. We learn that the Israeli “villages” where Palestinian fighters directed much of their activity were in fact agrarian settlements that were meant to form the first line of defense for Israel against Gaza, to be a “living wall” to repel any aggression. So rather than the “innocent” villagers portrayed by media, many inhabitants of those settlements were in fact armed defenders who had participated in the enclosure of Gaza for decades.
We also see the careful design and purpose of the seemingly random military maneuvers since October 7, 2023: the carpeted bombing that prepared for the ungrounding by bulldozers that plowed through homes, bodies, mosques, cemeteries, archeological sites, and infrastructure to render the land unrecognizable; the mad displacements of people that corralled them for murder and ultimately drove them to sequestration in the sand dunes of al-Mawasi where life cannot be supported. This is meant to be the holding place for the people of Gaza until their expulsion. It is all shown to us in maps, drawings and aerial photos. Unlike most books about Gaza, this one does not give us ground level views of people, homes and families, out of decency and privacy, Weizman explains. In the descriptions of Hind Rajab’s murder and those of several medics in March 2025, presented forensically as though in a courtroom – including minute-by-minute timelines and depictions of bullet paths – Weizman offers no embellishment or commentary, letting the facts speak for themselves: deliberate ethnocidal murder.
Episcopalians will be particularly interested in the summary of Forensic Architecture’s investigation of the bombing of al Ahli Hospital in October 2023, one of the first major bombings and still one of the deadliest. Within minutes of the bombing, Israel claimed it was a Palestinian rocket gone awry, the story immediately picked by and promoted by Western governments and media. Forensic Architecture’s investigation leaves no doubt that Israel bombed the hospital and reveals the lies and deception involved in covering it up.
Ungrounding: The Architecture of Genocide is an important addition to our canon. It forever transforms our understanding of this genocide. Though its tone is evidence-based, methodical and analytical, there is extraordinary and surprising intimacy in the descriptions of the land, its geologic and agricultural makeup, and its life over centuries. That intimacy and care arises from Weizman’s evident empathy. In a few personal passages, he shares the pain of several deaths of colleagues in the genocide, even as he and his team were working to report it.
Oddly, this exhaustive examination of a genocide does not leave us completely bereft, for the same clear-eyed vision that lays bare the architecture of genocide also detects some promise. Weizman notes that with careful study and inspection, some of the photos bear faint and subtle traces of that which Israel has attempted to erase. “These faint markers”, he writes, “are anchors for return”.
[Readers can find a lengthier, more detailed review of Ungrounding: The Architecture of Genocide here. Or listen to the author discuss his book on the +972 podcast here.]

